TL;DR

To check your cookie consent banner, open your site in a fresh private window and look at four things: does a banner appear, can visitors reject as easily as they accept, which cookies and tracking tags load before anyone clicks, and does anything change after they click Accept. In the UK and EU, advertising and most tracking cookies need consent first, so a pixel or analytics cookie that loads before the click is the most common problem. The free Cookie Consent Checker does this in a real browser and shows what loads before and after consent. It is an automated check, not legal advice.

What to check What good looks like Common problem
Banner appears A banner on first visit, before tracking starts No banner, but tracking tags on the page
Reject option Reject or Decline on the first layer, as easy to find as Accept Only "Accept" and "Settings"
Before consent Only strictly necessary cookies, no ad or analytics tags firing Meta Pixel, Google Analytics or TikTok firing straight away
After consent Tags you named in the banner start once a visitor accepts Nothing changes, because tags were already running
Policy links Privacy and cookie policy linked from the banner or footer No cookie policy, or a broken link
Google Consent Mode Consent signals passed to Google tags, if you advertise with Google Google tags running with no consent signal

Why your cookie banner matters

A cookie banner that does not actually hold tags back gives you the worst of both worlds: visitors see an annoying pop-up, and the tracking happens anyway. Regulators check for exactly that. In December 2025 the UK Information Commissioner's Office reported on its review of the top 1,000 UK websites, where it checked whether refusing advertising cookies is as easy as accepting them, and 564 sites improved their banners after the regulator got in touch. In France, the CNIL announced cookie fines of €325 million against Google and €150 million against Shein in September 2025.

It also matters for your marketing. If your banner blocks tags correctly but your ads setup does not pass consent signals on, platforms like Google Ads lose data from visitors who said yes.

How to check your cookie consent banner

1. Run a free consent check

Paste your homepage into the free Cookie Consent Checker. It loads the page in a fresh browser with no stored cookies, waits without clicking anything, and records:

  • whether a cookie banner appears, and which consent tool runs it if it recognises one (such as Cookiebot, CookieYes or OneTrust);
  • whether Accept and Reject buttons are both visible on the first layer;
  • cookies set and tracking tags fired before any choice is made, such as the Meta Pixel, Google Analytics 4, Google Ads and TikTok;
  • what loads after it clicks Accept, so you can see which tags wait for consent and which do not;
  • whether Google Consent Mode signals are present;
  • links to a privacy policy and a cookie policy.

It never fills in forms, and the only thing it clicks is the banner's Accept button. It checks your homepage once, from a server in the UK, and it does not click Reject, so test that by hand as described below.

2. Check by hand in a private window

  1. Open a private or incognito window, so no earlier choice is remembered.
  2. Open your site. The banner should appear before you do anything.
  3. Before clicking, right-click, choose Inspect, and open Application > Cookies (Chrome). Note what is there.
  4. Open the Network tab, reload, and filter for "facebook", "google-analytics", "googletagmanager" and "tiktok". Requests before you click mean those tags are not waiting for consent.
  5. Click Reject. Reload and confirm no new tracking cookies appear.
  6. Repeat in a new private window and click Accept. Confirm the tags you expect now load.

3. Read the banner as a visitor would

Can you see a way to reject on the first screen, without opening settings? Are Accept and Reject the same size and style, or is Reject a faint text link? Are any categories ticked in advance? Can visitors change their mind later, for example through a cookie settings link in the footer?

What the rules expect

This is general information, not legal advice. Check the regulator's guidance for your country, or ask a qualified adviser, for your own site.

UK

The Privacy and Electronic Communications Regulations (PECR) require consent before storing or reading non-essential cookies. The Data (Use and Access) Act 2025 changed this from 5 February 2026: consent is still required, but there are new exceptions, including cookies used only to collect statistics to improve your own service, provided visitors get clear information and a simple, free way to object. Advertising and cross-site tracking cookies still need consent. The ICO published its final guidance on storage and access technologies in April 2026, and its position remains that rejecting should be as easy as accepting.

EU

The ePrivacy Directive requires consent for non-essential cookies. The European Data Protection Board's cookie banner taskforce found that most national regulators treat a missing reject option on the first layer as an infringement, that pre-ticked boxes do not give valid consent, and that misleading button colours are a concern.

US

There is no single national cookie consent law. California requires businesses that sell or share personal information to offer a "Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information" link and to honour the Global Privacy Control browser signal as an opt-out. Some other states have their own privacy laws with similar opt-out rights.

How to fix the most common problems

  • Tags fire before consent. Move the Meta Pixel, Google Analytics, Google Ads and other marketing tags behind your consent tool. In Google Tag Manager, use consent settings or triggers that wait for the consent tool's signal. On Shopify, use a banner that works with Shopify's Customer Privacy API, which applies the visitor's choice to Shopify-managed pixels.
  • No reject button. Most consent tools let you add Reject all to the first layer in their settings.
  • No banner at all. If the check finds tracking tags but no banner, add a consent tool before running more ads.
  • Google Consent Mode missing. If you advertise with Google to visitors in the EEA, Google requires consent signals, including the version 2 settings for ad user data and ad personalisation. Most consent tools can send these for you.
  • No cookie policy. List the cookies you use, what they do and how to change your choice, and link it from the banner and footer.

Check again after every change

New apps, plugins, tag manager edits and redesigns are how tracking slips back in before consent. Run the check after each change and every few months, and keep a note of the date and result. For the wider picture, see the GDPR compliance checklist for small businesses.

Where Ergora helps

The free checker shows what your site does on a first visit. The Legal pack helps with the paperwork behind it: the Policies Library keeps your privacy policy and other policies with version history and review dates, the DSAR Tracker logs data requests against the 30-day deadline, and the Regulatory Tracker watches the ICO or other regulator pages you add and summarises what changed. Ergora is not a law firm and does not give legal advice.

If your banner blocks your Meta Pixel until visitors accept, check that the pixel still works afterwards with the Meta Pixel guide.

Verdict: Run the free Cookie Consent Checker on your homepage, make sure nothing but strictly necessary cookies loads before a choice, put Reject next to Accept, and check again after every new app or tag.

Frequently asked questions

How do I check if my cookie banner is working?

Open your site in a private window and, before clicking anything, check which cookies are set and which tracking requests are sent. Then accept and compare. A free cookie consent checker does both automatically.

Which cookies need consent?

In the UK and EU, cookies that are not strictly necessary to provide the service a visitor asked for, such as advertising and most tracking cookies. Since February 2026 the UK allows some analytics used only to improve your own service without consent, as long as visitors are told and can easily object.

Does my cookie banner need a reject button?

UK and EU regulators expect refusing to be as easy as accepting, which in practice means a Reject or Decline option on the first layer of the banner.

Is a cookie consent checker the same as a compliance audit?

No. An automated check shows what loads on one visit to one page. It does not review your policies, records or legal basis, so treat it as a first check, not a legal opinion.

See the Legal pack, with 50% off your first month.