TL;DR

Shopify's built-in email tool (listed in the Shopify App Store as Shopify Messaging, and still widely called Shopify Email) is cheaper and simpler: as of November 2026 the first 10,000 emails a month are free, then $1 per 1,000. Klaviyo costs more because it charges by active profiles ($20 a month at 500 profiles, $100 at around 5,000 on the third-party slider reading used below), but it gives you flows triggered by detailed shopper behaviour, finer splits and more control. For a store under a few thousand subscribers that needs a welcome series, cart recovery and a win-back, Shopify's tool is often enough. Move to Klaviyo when you need behaviour-based branching and the revenue justifies the bill.

Shopify Messaging (Shopify Email) Klaviyo
Pricing model Per email sent, 10,000 free a month Per active profile, free up to 250
Entry cost $0 up to 10,000 emails $20 a month at 500 profiles
Cost at about 5,000 subscribers sending 8 campaigns a month About $30 $100
Abandoned checkout emails Free, never counted Part of your normal sends
Automation templates Browse, cart, checkout, welcome, post-purchase, win-back, birthday, VIP Large flow library, plus build your own on any event
Branching and filters Not described on Shopify's help page; custom flows go through Shopify Flow Filters and splits on any event or property
Where it lives Inside Shopify admin Separate app, connected to Shopify

Both are covered at a high level in our Shopify email marketing starter guide. This post goes deeper on the cost maths and the automation differences. Note: the Klaviyo figures above come from Klaviyo's pricing page and its slider, read on 13 November 2026.

What you actually pay

Shopify Messaging

Shopify's help centre says Shopify Messaging is available on the Basic, Grow, Advanced and Plus plans. Each store gets 10,000 free emails per calendar month, shared across all campaigns, and unused emails do not roll over. Beyond that:

  • Up to 300,000 emails: $1.00 per 1,000.
  • 300,001 to 750,000: $0.65 per 1,000.
  • Beyond 750,000: $0.55 per 1,000.

Every recipient address counts as one email, so a campaign sent to 800 subscribers uses 800. Automations count towards the free 10,000, with one exception: abandoned checkout emails are always free. Extra charges appear on your Shopify bill as "Marketing emails", and you can set a monthly spending threshold to get an alert. Shopify's own example is two campaigns of 6,000 recipients: 12,000 emails, the first 10,000 free, 2,000 at $1 per 1,000, so $2.

Klaviyo

Klaviyo charges by active profiles, meaning contacts you can reach. Its pricing page shows a free plan for up to 250 profiles and 500 emails a month, the Email plan at $20 a month for 500 profiles with 5,000 emails, and the Marketing plan at $25 a month at the same size. Moving the slider on the same page (13 November 2026) gives $30 at 1,000 profiles, $100 at 5,000 and $150 at 10,000. Each tier includes ten times your profile count in emails. For a wider look at the tool itself, see our comparison of Ergora and Klaviyo.

Side by side

These examples count campaign emails only. Flow emails count towards Shopify's 10,000 as well (except abandoned checkout), so add them to your own numbers.

Store Campaign emails a month Shopify Messaging Klaviyo Email plan Difference per year
1,000 subscribers, 4 campaigns 4,000 $0 $30 $360
5,000 subscribers, 8 campaigns 40,000 $30 (30,000 over the free 10,000) $100 $840
10,000 subscribers, 8 campaigns 80,000 $70 (70,000 over) $150 $960

On price alone Shopify wins at every size above. The real question is whether Klaviyo's extra capability earns back $360 to $960 a year, and that depends on what you automate.

Automations compared

Shopify's help centre lists these Messaging automation templates:

  • Recover site visitors (email, SMS or WhatsApp): convert abandoned product browse, recover abandoned cart, recover abandoned checkout.
  • Welcome (email only): a welcome email with a discount, or a series with a discount email, two brand-building emails and a discount reminder if there is no purchase.
  • Post-purchase (email only): thank customers after their first and second purchases, upsell after the first purchase, win back customers after a set time since their last order, and drive online customers to nearby retail locations.
  • Customer appreciation (email only): a birthday email with a discount code, and a welcome for VIP customers (by default a third order and at least $1,000, or customers tagged VIP).

That covers a lot of what a small store needs. Shopify's page says you can edit an automation to change when a message is sent, and for custom automations it points you to Shopify Flow. It does not describe conditional splits or filters inside Messaging automations. Editing non-recovery automations needs a desktop device. By default automations send only to customers subscribed to marketing.

Klaviyo's flow library is larger, and its flows can start from any event it records, with filters and splits on top. From Klaviyo's help centre:

  • Abandoned checkout and browse abandonment flows with filters that stop buyers receiving reminders and cap re-entry (for example, not in this flow in the last 30 days).
  • A back in stock flow triggered when a shopper subscribes to a restock alert. Shopify's template list does not include one.
  • A sunset flow that tags unengaged subscribers for suppression.
  • Win-back timing based on your average buying cycle, not a fixed number of days.

None of that is out of reach for a growing store, but it is more than a store with a short product range and one buying pattern may ever use.

Segmentation and personalisation

Klaviyo stores every Shopify event (Placed Order, Ordered Product, Viewed Product, Added to Cart and more) with properties, so you can split on what was bought, how much was spent or what was browsed. Shopify's help pages describe segments and automations built from Shopify customer data inside the admin, which is simple to use, and they do not describe event-level splits.

Shopify's App Store listing also mentions AI generation and says Sidekick can personalise emails to match your brand.

When to stay on Shopify, and when to switch

Your situation Better fit
Under 2,000 subscribers, a few products, one email a week Shopify Messaging
You want a welcome, cart recovery and win-back and nothing else Shopify Messaging
You sell products people restock or replenish and want back in stock alerts Klaviyo
You need splits on order count, category or spend Klaviyo
Email is a major revenue channel and you test constantly Klaviyo
Your list is above 10,000 and mostly engaged Compare real costs; Klaviyo's depth may justify it

If you switch, do it carefully. Turn off Shopify's abandoned checkout emails the day you turn Klaviyo's flow on, as Klaviyo's guide advises, and keep one tool for each flow type so shoppers do not get duplicates. Judge results with Shopify and Klaviyo revenue reporting, because the two systems attribute revenue differently.

Where Ergora helps

Whichever email tool you use, writing the flows is the slow part. Ergora's Ecommerce pack connects to Shopify with one-click OAuth and to Klaviyo with a private API key, and its specialist drafts welcome, win-back, post-purchase and abandoned-cart sequences in your brand voice for you to review and publish in Klaviyo. It does not send email for you. See the Ecommerce pack.

Verdict: For most small Shopify stores the sensible path is to start on Shopify Messaging, because 10,000 free emails and free abandoned checkout emails cover a lot of ground at no cost. Switch to Klaviyo when you hit a specific limit: you want back in stock alerts, you need splits Shopify does not offer, or email revenue is large enough that better segmentation pays for the $360 to $960 a year in the examples above. If you do move to Klaviyo, Ergora can draft the flows; if you stay, you do not need Ergora for the email tool itself.

Frequently asked questions

Is Shopify Email free?

The first 10,000 emails each calendar month are free on Basic, Grow, Advanced and Plus, then it is $1 per 1,000 emails up to 300,000, as of November 2026. Abandoned checkout emails are always free.

Is Klaviyo better than Shopify Email?

Klaviyo offers more flexible automations and segmentation, but it costs more and is a separate tool. Shopify's built-in option is better value for small lists and simple needs.

Can I use Klaviyo and Shopify Email together?

You can, but give each flow type to one tool. Running both abandoned checkout flows means shoppers receive two reminders.

Do emails from flows count towards Shopify's 10,000 free emails?

Yes, marketing automations count, except abandoned checkout emails, which are free and never counted.

See the Ecommerce pack, with 50% off your first month.